Compare MP3 Players

abi>> Starts Mutiny at Zune Thoughts

zune-thoughts-mutinty.jpg

A month or so ago I wrote about how I don’t want the Zune to be cluttered with countless and useless features. See “8 Features I do NOT Want to See on the Zune”. Jason Dunn over at Zune Thoughts responded with counter arguments, which I still don’t agree with and did get some support from readers on my site when I pointed in his article out.

Volley for serve. The back and forth continues and now Zune Thoughts has a mutiny on their hands. In the latest post in this saga by one of Jason’s other writers, David Tucker, titled “Jason, You’re Wrong!”. David agrees with all of my 8 points except the Bluetooth feature. So David, I leave you with this: If we are keeping it simple and features out that only leaves Bluetooth headphone support. The problem is IEMs are becoming more and more popular being that they are excellent in sound quality and isolation. You cannot build wireless IEMs, Etymotic tried but they suck and they still have a wire. Sennheiser’s new high end wireless phones don’t even use Bluetooth. So my point is Bluetooth as a means to transport audio to headphones is not a good solution and Bluetooth being used in any other way is a feature to clutter the Zune.

  • Submit this article to Del.icio.us
  • Submit this article to Reddit
  • Submit this article to Furl
  • Submit this article to StumbleUpon

Comments

Slaughter on January 11, 2008 9:22 PM

It's as I said in the Comments in the other post: Jason tried to write a rebuttal, but ended up agreeing on half your points. He should be fired!

yes for media centric features on January 12, 2008 4:48 AM

bluetooth in pmp's will be a godsend for hearing impaired people with recent hearing aids sporting bluetooth.

Tony Jasinski on January 12, 2008 3:54 PM

I love this website, and you guys have given me some good support in the past...

But I do disagree with the concern over 'too many features'.

One of the dissappointments that I have with my Creative Zen Vision M is that it doesn't have any games (for example).

I will choose my next player based on having a full range of features....

EnzoTen (Grahm) on January 12, 2008 4:50 PM

My concern for "too many features" is not for all players. My campaign is to keep at least one of them music centric by not cluttering the player with crap- so that consumers at least have that choice.

Jason Dunn on January 16, 2008 6:40 PM

@ Slaughter:

I'm not sure if you're kidding or not, but a rebuttal isn't always a 100% disagreement - at least, not among clear-thinking individuals (I'm sure there are politicians out there that can disagree 100% with someone). My response was really designed to spur discussion, which it did - even amongst my own team members. As long as we're all talking about what we want to see, it's all good! If you're really being serious, you need to lighten up, pronto.

And since I own the site, I don't think I'm going to fire myself. ;-)

Jason Dunn
www.zunethoughts.com

Jason Dunn on January 16, 2008 6:58 PM

Oh, regarding Bluetooth support, someone in our forums pointed out an excellent reason for Bluetooth: transmitting audio to car decks. There's a Pioneer deck that has a BT chip in it, so you can use BT to send audio to your deck without needing a custom dock, a line-in jack, etc. Seems like a much better use of BT than headphones to me!

Jason Dunn
www.zunethoughts.com

Zsan on March 15, 2008 5:31 PM

The mroe features, the merrier. As long as there's options tu turn them off, and those options aren't hard to access, change, or understand.

Just a menu with:

Bluetooth: Yes/No
FM radio: Yes/No
Touch screen: Yes/No

Etc/etc/etc is not that bad, and pretty easy.

Leave a comment

  • Name:
  • E-mail:
  • URL:
  • Remember info?

Type the characters you see in the picture above.


abi Editor's Choice
  • Samsung P2
    Samsung P2

    The Samsung P2 has been gaining quite a following lately and rightfully so. If you are looking for something well designed, innovative, and feature packed; you should look into this full touch screen wonder. The Bluetooth feature set is what I find to be the most intriguing, with the ability to tether to your phone to make calls or wirelessly transfer with no restrictions to other P2s. Check out the review or stop by our ever growing P2 forums to get the latest info.

  • Toshiba Gigabeat T400
    toshiba gigabeat t400

    The Gigabeat T400 is without a doubt my favorite flash player at the moment. It does have one major setback in that it only comes in a 4GB, shame on you Toshiba. What makes me love this player is it's ultra slick sexy design, very easy- just pick up and use interface, and killer sound quality that would make Cowon users envious. This player is a must buy for anyone who sports a premium set of headphones. Full review to come but you should really just buy one.

  • SanDisk Sansa Clip
    SanDisk Sansa Clip

    The Clip has a fantastic little form factor; cheap in build quality but very rugged. The interface is simple and relatively straight forward. The features on the clip are more or less average, mostly identical to the Sansa Express. However, what earns this player a spot in Editor’s Choice is the superb sound quality; you will not find another player at this size and price that can match it. Read the full review or go ahead and buy it.

  • Cowon iAudio D2
    Cowon iAudio D2

    The D2 is a fantastic sounding PMP with a very nice looking screen and a tone of features. One of the best features of the D2 is the SDHC slot allowing you to add another 32GB to this small wonder. The touch interface does not lend well to on the move operation, but it is not enough to keep it from being an editor’s choice. You can find usually find it at Amazon for the best price and before to check out the review.

  • JAYS q-JAYS
    JAYS q-JAYS

    The q-JAYS are great in ear phones. They offer excellent clarity, silky treble, realistic midrange, and a nice bass response. They're comfortable, incredibly tiny, and come with a huge selection of accessories. While they certainly are analytic phones, they're still fun to listen to. The q-JAYS respond well to EQing, and can be tweaked to fit almost anyone's sound preference. Recommended for anyone owning a good sounding player and well encoded audio files. Check out our review.